Shootouts: the ultimate coin flip

Penalty shootouts are the most dramatic moments of any World Cup and, for bettors, among the least predictable. They only appear in the knockout stages, when a tie is level after extra time. This guide explains the markets and, more importantly, why you should treat them with real caution.

There are no tips here and no predictions. The whole point of this guide is that shootouts resist prediction — and understanding that is the most useful thing you can take into these markets.

Where shootouts fit in the knockouts

From the round of 16 onward, a level knockout tie goes to extra time and then, if still level, penalties. So shootout markets are only live in the knockout phase. If you are betting on how a knockout match is decided, our knockout stage betting guide gives the wider context.

Common shootout-related markets:

  • Tie to be decided on penalties: yes/no on a shootout happening.
  • To qualify / to advance: which team progresses, including via penalties.
  • Method of qualification: in normal time, extra time or penalties.
  • Correct score after extra time and related draw-no-bet style markets.

Why shootouts are close to a coin flip

Once a match reaches penalties, almost everything that separated the two teams over 120 minutes stops mattering. Both sides are exhausted, the pressure is extreme, and the outcome comes down to a series of individual, high-stakes moments. The honest reality, borne out repeatedly, is that a shootout between two evenly matched teams is close to 50/50, regardless of which side was the favourite in the tie.

That is why “to advance” prices for a tie heading toward penalties tend to converge — the market knows the favourite’s edge largely evaporates. Reputation, “big-game experience” and past shootout records are comforting narratives, but they offer very little predictive power. A team with a poor shootout history can win the next one; a “cool” team can crumble.

The traps to avoid

  • Backing the “better” team to win the shootout. Their quality earned them a favourite tag over 90 or 120 minutes; it barely applies once it is one kick at a time.
  • Reading too much into records. Small samples of past shootouts tell you almost nothing about the next one.
  • In-play over-confidence. Betting mid-shootout, kick by kick, is pure adrenaline. Prices move violently and the outcome can flip in seconds. Our in-play live betting guide explains why fast-moving markets punish impulsive bets.

Predicting a shootout will happen

Some bettors focus not on who wins but on whether a tie goes to penalties at all. This is slightly more approachable — cagey, evenly matched knockout ties are more likely to stay level — but it is still uncertain. A single moment of quality can settle a tie in normal time and void the whole idea. Treat it as a fun, speculative market, not a reliable one.

Betting on shootouts sensibly

  • Accept the coin-flip reality: keep stakes small on any shootout market.
  • Do not chase a shootout result you feel “robbed” by — that is exactly the emotional trap these moments create.
  • Compare prices across licensed betting sites before staking.
  • A free bet is a low-cost way to have a punt on a shootout market; read the terms first.
  • New to knockout markets? Start with our football betting guide.

Penalty shootouts are unforgettable to watch, and there is nothing wrong with a small stake to sharpen the tension. Just never convince yourself you can read them. The drama comes precisely from the fact that nobody can. Small stakes, a clear head, and an acceptance of the coin flip are the only sensible way to bet on them.

18+. Gambling involves real financial risk. If it stops being fun, take a break — play responsibly.